Engagement groups explained – Why brands should look beyond the numbers

I have a full-time job in marketing, and in my free time and on weekends, I create content. Through my job, I’ve worked with and negotiated with travel influencers, so I’ve been on both sides of the industry. Because of that, I feel well-placed to talk about this topic. I want to focus on engagement groups on social media, mainly Instagram. Social media has become extremely competitive – there are so many opportunities for content creators, and more and more people are moving away from traditional jobs to pursue it. But success rarely comes overnight, and sometimes it doesn’t come at all. That’s why many creators turn to engagement boosts, just to make it look like they’re on the right track. So, are engagement groups good or not? In the short term, yes.Engagement groups, or “pods”, where people like and comment on each other’s posts, are designed to give early engagement, which can sometimes help a post get noticed by the algorithm. They can:* Give your post quick likes and comments within the first hour* Make your account look more active* Give your post some initial traction But in the long term? No. Most engagement groups include a variety of accounts with very different types of content that often aren’t relevant to one another. I know this from experience – I was in one for a short period. While there were a few creators whose content I genuinely enjoyed, most of the others didn’t interest me at all. And vice versa. (PS – there was a guy posting only about sports – him watching football with a beer in hand, him going to a sports bar, what the hell?) Social media attention spans are already short, and they shrink even more when the content isn’t engaging. Yet, engagement groups expect you to interact out of obligation. This is usually how “requirements” for an engagement group look like. Why would you follow or comment on content you don’t care about? The algorithm notices this, too – it’s smarter than we give it credit for. Here’s an example: I mostly post travel reels – personal experiences, memes, funny moments, beautiful places, and travel itineraries. When I’m not traveling abroad, I showcase places in London – restaurants, museums, hotels, and other local spots. That’s also the kind of content I follow, so the algorithm usually shows me what I actually want to see. Now imagine being added to an engagement group where I start seeing poorly filmed reels, personal videos of couples kissing, tips about how to raise your children, or other stuff that I simply don’t care about. I don’t have the patience to watch them until the end – and yet, I’m expected to comment so someone else will return the favour. It’s exhausting. Engagement is a two-way street, especially for micro-creators, I get it. It’s great to receive it, but you also need to give it back. I have a few creators outside of engagement groups with whom I’ve developed genuine online relationships – we comment on each other’s content because we actually enjoy it. Or at least I am, and try to leave meaningful comments where I can. That’s real engagement from real people. From a brand’s perspective, this matters a lot. When I research influencers for a campaign, I look closely at who is actually engaging with their content. Hundreds of likes and comments don’t mean much if they all come from other content creators. These people are unlikely to become paying customers or clients – in fact, they’re more likely to message you asking for free services after seeing someone else collaborate with you. These are vanity metrics. Metrics that look impressive on the surface, but don’t reflect real audience interest. What actually matters on Instagram right now: 🥇 1. Shares – probably the strongest public signal. If someone sends your reel to a friend or reposts it, Instagram reads that as: “this is valuable enough to recommend”. 🥈 2. Saves (also strong) – this signals as “I want to come back to this”. Instagram treats this as high-value content (educational, inspiring, useful, etc). 🥉 3. Views/Watch time – Views tell you reach, not necessarily quality, but watch time is important because it actually tells Instagram whether your reel is actually engaging. 💬 4. Comments (good, but context-dependent) – they show engagement, but they’re easier to “fake” with low-effort (“So nice”, emojis, etc). 👍 5. Likes (the weakest signal now) – basically a “light approval tap”. They matter, but Instagram has heavily deprioritised them compared to saves/shares/watch time. How can you spot creators who comment out of obligation? Well, it’s pretty easy. Many of them have usernames that give away the type of content they create – for example: “jessicaeats” or “erikalondon” or “travellover”. Their comments tend to be generic and superficial: “😍😍”, “Beautiful”, “So nice”, “Lovely”. I actually find it funny. I might post a serious reel about a travel experience or a city’s pros and cons, and the comments I get are still “So nice”. They’re probably leaving hundreds of likes and robotic comments every day – it’s a pattern the algorithm picks up. Genuine engagement, on the other hand, comes from real interest. People who care about your content leave thoughtful, personal comments, even if sometimes these comments are negative. For brands, this distinction is crucial. Many prefer to work with creators who have slightly lower reach but whose engagement comes from “normal” people rather than hundreds of likes from other content creators who will never convert into customers. The downsides of engagement groups are clear: Low-quality engagement – Generic comments and likes that the algorithm can detect as inauthentic. Wrong audience – Members often aren’t genuinely interested, which can hurt your reach. Time-consuming – You spend hours interacting with content that may not be relevant, with very little return. I actually looked into a few creators to see who’s engaging with their posts – and just as I suspected, it’s mostly other

Engagement groups explained – Why brands should look beyond the numbers Read More »